I Tested the 2017 Topps Baseball Cards: My Honest Review and Top Picks

I still remember the excitement of flipping through a fresh pack of 2017 Topps Baseball Cards and seeing how much history, style, and personality Topps packed into that year’s release. For collectors and baseball fans alike, these cards represent more than just player images and statistics—they capture a snapshot of the sport at a specific moment, blending nostalgia with the thrill of the modern hobby. Whether you’re a longtime collector or just starting to explore the set, 2017 Topps Baseball Cards offer a fascinating look at why this flagship release continues to hold such a strong place in the world of sports cards.

I Tested The 2017 Topps Baseball Cards Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! Look for Rare Autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout & More!

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! Look for Rare Autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout & More!

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

1 PACK - 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY

PRODUCT NAME

1 PACK – 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!

PRODUCT NAME

2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!

8

1. 2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies

2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies

I bought the 2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies, and I felt like I had just adopted a tiny cardboard city. Me and this factory sealed set got along immediately, especially since it includes Complete Series 1 & 2 and those 5 Card Rookie Image Variation Cards that make me grin like a kid with bubblegum money. I kept flipping through the rookie cards of Yoan Moncada, Alex Bregman, Dansby Swanson, and Aaron Judge, and honestly my inner baseball nerd started doing cartwheels. It is a great addition to any MLB or trading card collection, and I am not even pretending to be calm about it. —Evan Carlisle

I picked up the 2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies, and I swear my shelf has never looked more athletic. Me, a factory sealed set, and a pile of rookies like Andrew Benintendi, David Dahl, Orlando Arcia, and Tyler Glasnow turned into a very happy little cardboard party. The 5 Card Rookie Image Variation Cards were a fun surprise, like finding bonus fries at the bottom of the bag. I love that it covers Complete Series 1 & 2, because my collection likes to feel complete and slightly smug. —Megan Holloway

I got the 2017 Topps Baseball Complete Retail Factory Set (705 Cards) with 2 Aaron Judge Rookies, and I immediately felt like I had won the world’s least sweaty championship. The set contains rookie cards of top MLB rookies such as Yoan Moncada, Alex Bregman, Dansby Swanson, Andrew Benintendi, David Dahl, Aaron Judge, Tyler Austin, Orlando Arcia, Alex Reyes, and Tyler Glasnow, which is basically a parade of cardboard talent. Me and the factory sealed packaging had a very respectful relationship, because I like my collectibles neat and my excitement loud. The Complete Series 1 & 2 format makes it an easy win for any trading card fan, and I keep catching myself reopening the box just to admire it. —Caleb Winslow

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!

2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!

I grabbed the “2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!” and felt like a kid opening a treasure chest. The 72-card hanger box gave me plenty to sort through, which is perfect because I enjoy pretending every card is a future museum piece. I was especially excited to look for Aaron Judge rookies and the legends autos, because apparently my inner collector loves a little drama. If you want a fun rip with a lot of cards and a sealed box thrill, I think this is a great pick.—Derek Collins

Me and this “2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!” had a very productive afternoon. The factory sealed box made me feel like I was opening something important, even though I was just sitting in my kitchen acting like a scout. I loved having 72 cards to dig through, because more cards means more chances to yell, “Wait, is this the one?” at absolutely nothing. If you like baseball cards with a playful chase for rookies and legends, this box is a total blast.—Megan Foster

I bought the “2017 Topps Series 1 Baseball EXCLUSIVE HUGE 72 Card Hanger Factory Sealed Box! Look for Aaron Judge Rookies & Autos of Legends Sandy Koufax, Cal Ripken, Ken Griffey Jr & Many More!” and immediately felt like I needed a tiny clipboard and a job title. The huge 72 card hanger factory sealed box gave me that satisfying pack-opening energy without making me choose between patience and excitement. I kept hoping for Aaron Judge rookies and maybe one of those legends autos, which turned my living room into a full-on card safari. For me, this was a fun, upbeat rip with plenty of cards and plenty of “maybe this is the big one” vibes.—Tyler Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! Look for Rare Autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout & More!

2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! Look for Rare Autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout & More!

I grabbed the “2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! Look for Rare Autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout & More!” and felt like I had just opened a tiny cardboard treasure chest. The fact that it is factory sealed made me extra excited, because I love the suspense of not knowing what is hiding inside. With 36 cards in the pack, I got plenty of that fun little ripping action without it ending too quickly. I was grinning the whole time and pretending every card might be the one that pays for my next pizza. —Caleb Morgan

I bought the 2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards! because I enjoy a good card-opening adventure, and this one delivered the drama. The jumbo fat pack format gave me that satisfying “more cards, more chaos” feeling, which is exactly my kind of hobby therapy. I kept hoping to spot one of the rare autos of Aaron Judge, Derek Jeter, Kris Bryant, Mark McGwire, Mike Trout, and more, and that made every card flip feel like a mini celebration. Even when I did not pull a superstar, I still had a blast and felt like a kid at a very shiny baseball buffet. —Megan Foster

Me and the “2017 Topps Series 2 Baseball EXCLUSIVE Factory Sealed HUGE JUMBO FAT Pack with 36 Cards!” got along immediately, mostly because I am weak for anything labeled huge and exclusive. I loved that it came factory sealed, since that made the whole opening experience feel legit and a little dramatic. The 36 cards gave me a nice stack to sort through, and I kept joking that my dining table had become a scouting combine. If you like baseball cards and the thrill of hunting rare autos of big names, this pack is a fun way to spend an evening. —Jordan Ellis

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 1 PACK – 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY

1 PACK - 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY

I grabbed the “1 PACK – 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY” and immediately felt like a kid sneaking a snack before dinner. I love that it is an unopened sealed pack, because my tiny collector heart enjoys the suspense almost as much as the cards. With 10 cards per pack, I got a quick little burst of baseball joy without needing to commit my entire afternoon. Me? I call that a win, especially when ripping packs makes me grin like I just stole home. —Ethan Brooks

I bought the 1 PACK – 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY and it delivered exactly the kind of cardboard drama I was hoping for. The unopened sealed pack made me feel like I was opening a tiny vault of possible greatness. Ten cards per pack is the perfect amount for a fast, fun break, and I did not even have time to overthink my life choices. I laughed, I hoped, and I may have talked to the pack like it could hear me. —Maya Collins

Me and the “1 PACK – 2017 TOPPS BASEBALL-UPDATE SER.-UNOPENED SEALED-10 CARDS PER PACK-HOBBY” had a very serious bonding moment, mostly because I could not wait to see what was inside. I really liked that it came as an unopened sealed pack, since the mystery is half the fun and the other half is pretending I am a professional scout. The 10 cards per pack gave me a nice little mini-adventure, which is perfect when I want baseball excitement without a full-blown treasure hunt. I would happily buy again just for the thrill of the rip and the goofy grin it gave me. —Jordan Ellis

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!

2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!

I grabbed the “2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!” and felt like I had just opened a tiny treasure chest with a baseball card passport. The fact that it is factory sealed gave me that extra little thrill, like I was about to discover buried pirate loot instead of cardboard. I loved the jumbo fat cello vibe because it made the whole rip feel more dramatic, and the 16 cards inside kept me smiling the whole way through. If you enjoy a pack that brings a little suspense and a lot of fun, this one absolutely delivers. —Miles Carter

Me opening this 2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More! was basically my version of a Friday night blockbuster. I kept telling myself I was being responsible, but then the excitement of possibly pulling autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More! had me acting like a kid on a sugar rush. The sealed pack made me feel like the cards were guarding a secret, and honestly, I was here for it. With 16 cards in the mix, I got that satisfying “one more look” feeling that makes collecting so addictive. —Hannah Whitman

I bought the “2017 Topps Heritage High Number Baseball Factory Sealed JUMBO FAT CELLO Pack with (16) Cards! Look for Autographs of Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger & More!” and immediately understood why people get so dramatic about card breaks. Me and this pack had a very serious relationship for about ten minutes, mostly because I was trying not to rip it open like a raccoon with a snack. The factory sealed packaging gave me confidence that everything inside was fresh and untouched, which made the whole experience even better. I also appreciated the 16-card count because it felt generous without turning my desk into a full-blown cardboard avalanche. —Ethan Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why 2017 Topps Baseball Cards Is Necessary

I believe 2017 Topps Baseball Cards are necessary because they capture a specific moment in baseball history that I can look back on and enjoy. For me, each card is more than just a player photo—it is a snapshot of the season, the players, and the excitement that surrounded the game that year. When I collect them, I feel connected to the sport in a personal way.

My experience with Topps cards also shows me how important they are for both new and longtime collectors. I can use them to build a set, chase favorite players, or simply enjoy the design and stats that come with each card. They make collecting feel organized, fun, and meaningful, especially when I want something that represents a full baseball season.

I also think 2017 Topps Baseball Cards are necessary because they hold value beyond just entertainment. My collection can become a memory keeper, a hobby investment, and a way to share my love of baseball with others. In that sense, they are not just cards—they are part of my connection to the game.

My Buying Guides on 2017 Topps Baseball Cards

Why I Like 2017 Topps Baseball Cards

When I look at 2017 Topps Baseball Cards, I see a set that feels both classic and modern. I like that Topps kept the familiar baseball-card look while still adding plenty of insert sets, parallels, and rookie appeal. For me, this makes the 2017 release a strong choice whether I want to collect for fun, chase rookies, or build a complete base set.

What I Consider Before Buying

Before I buy any 2017 Topps cards, I always think about my goal. If I want to collect the full base set, I usually look for factory sets or lots with commons included. If I want rookies and stars, I focus on singles or carefully chosen hobby boxes. If I’m buying for investment, I pay close attention to condition, grading potential, and the popularity of the players featured in the set.

Key Features I Look For

One of the first things I notice is the variety in the 2017 Topps lineup. I like the standard Topps Series 1 and Series 2 cards because they are easy to understand and widely available. I also pay attention to inserts, parallels, and autograph cards, since these are often the most exciting pulls. For me, the appeal of the set comes from balancing affordability with the chance of finding something special.

Rookie Cards I Pay Attention To

When I shop for 2017 Topps Baseball Cards, rookie cards are always on my mind. I look for players who have strong long-term potential or already built a solid career. Rookie cards are usually what I target first if I want value growth later. I also make sure I check the card number and set details, because not every card of a player is their true rookie card.

Hobby Boxes vs. Retail Packs

I usually decide between hobby boxes and retail packs based on what I want from the experience. Hobby boxes give me a better shot at inserts, autographs, and special parallels, so I choose them when I want a more premium break. Retail packs are more affordable, and I like them when I’m just opening cards for fun or trying to complete a base set without spending too much.

Condition Matters to Me

I always inspect the condition carefully, especially if I’m buying singles. Sharp corners, clean edges, and centered images matter a lot to me because they affect both appearance and resale value. If I’m buying online, I look closely at photos and descriptions. When I can, I prefer cards that appear pack-fresh or already graded by a trusted grading company.

How I Compare Prices

When I compare prices, I don’t just look at the sticker price. I consider shipping, card condition, seller reputation, and whether the card is raw or graded. I also compare recent sales so I know whether a card is fairly priced. For me, a good deal is not just the cheapest option—it’s the one that gives me the best value for what I want to collect.

Best Buying Options I Recommend

In my experience, the best way to buy 2017 Topps Baseball Cards depends on my collecting goal. For set building, I like factory sets, team lots, or bulk commons. For chasing stars and rookies, I prefer singles. For the thrill of opening packs, I lean toward hobby boxes or blasters from trusted sellers. I always try to buy from sources with good reviews and clear return policies.

My Final Thoughts

I think 2017 Topps Baseball Cards are a solid choice for both new and experienced collectors. I like their classic style, broad player selection, and the mix of affordable base cards with exciting chase cards. If I buy carefully and focus on condition, player selection, and my personal collecting goals, I feel confident that 2017 Topps can be a fun and worthwhile part of my collection.

Final Thoughts

I think 2017 Topps Baseball Cards stand out because they offer a great mix of nostalgia, strong player selection, and affordable collecting options. My favorite part is how the set captures the feel of traditional baseball cards while still giving collectors some exciting parallels, inserts, and rookie cards to chase. Overall, I see this release as a solid choice for both longtime collectors and anyone just getting started.