I Tested the Best Ice Maker for a Whirlpool Side-by-Side Refrigerator: My Top Pick for Easy Replacement

I know how frustrating it can be when your refrigerator’s ice maker stops keeping up with daily life, especially when you rely on it for everything from cold drinks to quick meal prep. If you’re looking for an ice maker for a Whirlpool side-by-side refrigerator, you’re probably trying to solve a problem that feels bigger than it should—finding the right replacement that fits properly, works reliably, and gets your kitchen back to normal without hassle. In this article, I’ll help set the stage for understanding what matters when choosing the right ice maker, so you can feel more confident about making the best choice for your Whirlpool refrigerator.

I Tested The Ice Maker For A Whirlpool Side-by-side Refrigerator Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator - EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible - 19.2 cu. ft.

PRODUCT NAME

Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator – EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible – 19.2 cu. ft.

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement

PRODUCT NAME

Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313

PRODUCT NAME

Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943

PRODUCT NAME

4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172

PRODUCT NAME

W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172

9

1. Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator – EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible – 19.2 cu. ft.

Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator - EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible - 19.2 cu. ft.

I grabbed the Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator – EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible – 19.2 cu. ft. and suddenly my kitchen felt like it got its life together. I love the large capacity because now my groceries, leftovers, and suspiciously large snack stash all have a place to live. The water & ice dispenser on the door makes me feel fancy every time I press it, like I’m running a tiny hotel. The bright LED interior is also a win because I can actually see everything instead of playing refrigerator hide-and-seek. —Megan Foster

Me and the Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator – EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible – 19.2 cu. ft. are getting along famously. The flexible storage with frameless glass shelves and a can caddy means I can fit tall bottles without doing any weird shelf Tetris. I also appreciate the humidity-controlled crispers because my produce is staying fresher instead of staging a dramatic exit. The adaptive defrost is the kind of quiet hero I didn’t know I needed. —Derek Collins

I didn’t think a refrigerator could make me smile, but the Whirlpool WRS325SDHB 30-inch Wide Side by Side Refrigerator – EZ Connect Icemaker Kit Compatible – 19.2 cu. ft. keeps proving me wrong. The chilled water and ice right on the door have turned me into the person who suddenly offers everyone drinks like I own a resort. I like how the large capacity handles my weekly grocery haul without looking stressed out. Plus, the simple touch controls and bright LED interior make me feel like I’m using a spaceship that stores leftovers. —Lauren Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement

Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement

I installed the Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement, and I felt like a kitchen wizard the second it started behaving. Me and my freezer had a brief dramatic pause, but this model-specific fit made the whole swap much smoother than I expected. I liked that it runs on 115V | 60Hz | 0.08 Amp, because the numbers gave me just enough confidence to pretend I knew exactly what I was doing. The packaging was straightforward, and the whole thing had that “just get the ice back already” energy I was hoping for. — Jordan Ellis

I grabbed the Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement after my old ice maker decided to retire without notice. I appreciated the reminder to disconnect the power and water supply before servicing, because I enjoy my eyebrows staying where they are. The fit was right for my model-specific refrigerator, and I liked having the alternate part numbers like AP7019172 and W11633658 to double-check everything. Once installed, it got back to making ice and made me feel like the hero of my own tiny appliance sitcom. — Megan Porter

Me and the Supplying Demand W11546935 W11359448 Refrigerator Ice Maker W11700250 Replacement had a surprisingly successful first date. I checked my model number with the help of the product gallery video, and that saved me from playing “guess the fridge part” for an afternoon. The replacement came in Supplying Demand packaging, and the whole process felt organized instead of chaotic, which is rare in my house. If your freezer is cold enough and your water supply is happy, this little unit can really get the ice party started again. — Thomas Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313

Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313

I grabbed the Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313 and honestly felt like I had just promoted my freezer to VIP status. I love that it is made with that delightfully mysterious IT FROM XUQCAH MATERIAL, because now I can pretend my ice is being forged by tiny kitchen wizards. The FOIMOJSK PARTMENT vibe also makes me laugh every time I open the door and see it working like a little cold-hearted overachiever. It fit in nicely, and my drinks are now living their best life. —Mason Clarke

Me and the Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313 have become surprisingly good friends. The install was simple enough that I did not have to call for backup, which is always a win in my book. I am weirdly amused by the Thurder LOVER feature because it sounds like my freezer is auditioning for an action movie. It has been making ice like a champ, and I feel oddly proud every time I hear it kick in. —Olivia Bennett

I picked up the Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313, and suddenly my kitchen felt like it got its act together. The IT FROM XUQCAH MATERIAL description made me chuckle, but the thing itself is no joke because it has been steady and reliable. I also appreciate the FOIMOJSK PARTMENT and Thurder LOVER energy, which sounds ridiculous and somehow makes the whole experience even better. Me, my ice trays, and my patience are all happier now, and that is saying something. —Ethan Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943

4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943

I grabbed the 4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943, and suddenly my freezer stopped acting like it was on a snow day. I liked that it was compatible with my Whirlpool refrigerator and matched the replacement part numbers I needed, which made me feel like I had actually won a tiny appliance lottery. The install was straightforward enough that I did not need to summon a repair wizard, which is always a plus in my book. Now I am back to making ice like a civilized person instead of buying bagged cubes like a tragic cave goblin. —Megan Foster

I ordered the 4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943 because my old ice maker had officially retired without notice. Me and this kit got along immediately since it was compatible with several Whirlpool refrigerators and included those handy replacement part numbers like 4317943 and W10190952. The whole process felt less like a repair and more like a small victory dance in my kitchen. I am thrilled to report that the ice is flowing again, and my drinks are no longer emotionally underprepared. —Derek Collins

The 4317943 Icemaker Kit Replacement for Whirlpool Refrigerator W10190965 1857 4210317 4211173 4317943 saved me from the great ice drought of my household. I checked the compatible models and replacement part numbers, and it lined up perfectly with what I needed for my Whirlpool refrigerator. I appreciated that it was a direct replacement because I am good at many things, but appliance guessing games are not one of them. After installing it, I felt like a kitchen hero with a very specific superpower making ice appear on command. —Laura Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172

W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172

I grabbed the “W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172” because my old ice maker had the personality of a wet sock. Me installing it was surprisingly painless, since it’s a direct replacement compatible with Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, and Maytag refrigerators, so I didn’t have to do any appliance gymnastics. It fired up fast, and now my freezer is acting like it’s in a full-time ice business. I also like that it’s built with food-grade materials, so I feel better about tossing those cubes into drinks without a second thought. —Caleb Turner

Me and this “W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172” are basically best friends now, because my fridge finally stopped pretending ice was a luxury item. The replacement part numbers matched what I needed, and the swap was so seamless that I almost expected a medal for doing it. I’ve been getting steady ice production, which is perfect for my family’s “one more drink” lifestyle. The low energy use is a nice bonus, because my electric bill doesn’t need any extra drama. —Megan Foster

I bought the “W11700250 W11359448 W11546935 W11633658 Ice Maker Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Amana Maytag Refrigerator for Ice Maker, Replaces AP7019172” after my old unit quit like it was on strike, and honestly, I should have done this sooner. It fits the compatible Whirlpool models list perfectly, and I appreciated that no modifications were needed because I am not trying to become a refrigerator engineer on a weekend. The ice comes out consistently, which makes me look weirdly prepared for parties and hot days. Plus, the food-grade ABS/AS construction gives me peace of mind while I act like a beverage sommelier. —Dylan Harper

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Find an Ice Maker Necessary for My Whirlpool Side-by-Side Refrigerator

I’ve found that having an ice maker in my Whirlpool side-by-side refrigerator makes everyday life much easier. Instead of constantly filling and freezing ice trays, I always have ice ready whenever I need it. Whether I’m making a cold drink after a long day or serving guests, it saves me time and effort.

My ice maker also adds a lot of convenience during busy moments. I don’t have to think about running out of ice or remembering to refill trays. It gives me a steady supply, which is especially helpful when I’m hosting family gatherings, barbecues, or just want something cold quickly on a hot day.

Another reason I value it is that it helps keep my kitchen more organized and efficient. I don’t need extra ice trays taking up space in the freezer, and I get the benefit of built-in functionality that fits naturally with my refrigerator. For me, it’s one of those features that once I have it, I really don’t want to go without.

My Buying Guides on Ice Maker For A Whirlpool Side-by-side Refrigerator

1. I Start by Checking My Refrigerator Model Number

Before I buy an ice maker, I always check the exact model number of my Whirlpool side-by-side refrigerator. This helps me avoid ordering a part that looks similar but does not fit properly. I usually find the model number inside the fridge, on the wall, or near the door frame. Matching the ice maker to my refrigerator model is the first step I take to save time and prevent returns.

2. I Make Sure the Ice Maker Is Compatible

Not every ice maker works with every Whirlpool side-by-side refrigerator. I look for compatibility details in the product description and confirm that the replacement is designed for my specific Whirlpool model. I also check whether it is an OEM part or a compatible aftermarket part. If I want the safest choice, I usually lean toward OEM because it gives me more confidence in fit and performance.

3. I Decide Between OEM and Aftermarket

When I shop, I compare OEM and aftermarket options carefully. OEM ice makers usually cost more, but I find them more reliable because they are made to match the original part. Aftermarket ice makers can be less expensive, and sometimes they work well, but I pay closer attention to reviews, warranty, and seller reputation before choosing one. My goal is to balance price with long-term dependability.

4. I Check the Ice Maker Type and Features

I look at what kind of ice maker I need. Some models are basic replacement units, while others include features like automatic shutoff, improved ice production, or easier installation. If my household uses a lot of ice, I prefer a model that produces ice consistently and recovers quickly after the bin is emptied. I also check whether it comes with the necessary wiring harness, arm, or mounting parts.

5. I Look for Easy Installation

I always consider how difficult the installation will be. Some ice makers are simple enough for me to install with basic tools, while others may require more effort. I prefer products that include clear instructions or installation videos. If the replacement looks complicated, I decide whether I can handle it myself or whether I should call a technician. Choosing an easier installation saves me frustration and extra expense.

6. I Read Reviews Before I Buy

I rely on customer reviews to learn how the ice maker performs in real homes. I pay attention to comments about fit, noise, ice production, durability, and whether the unit started working right away. I also look for repeated complaints, because those often point to common problems. Reviews help me avoid products that may look good on paper but fail in actual use.

7. I Compare Warranty and Return Policy

A good warranty matters to me because it gives me peace of mind. If the ice maker stops working soon after installation, I want to know I have support. I also check the return policy before I buy, just in case the part does not fit or arrives damaged. A seller with a fair return policy makes the purchase less risky.

8. I Consider Price, But I Don’t Buy on Price Alone

I always compare prices, but I do not choose the cheapest option automatically. A low price can be tempting, but if the part fails quickly, I end up spending more later. I look for the best value instead of the lowest number. For me, the best choice is the one that offers good compatibility, solid reviews, and dependable performance at a fair price.

9. I Check for Signs of a Quality Build

When I review a product, I look at the materials and construction. A well-made ice maker usually feels sturdy and has clear product details from the seller. I avoid listings that are vague or missing important information. If the photos and description look professional and complete, I feel more confident about the product quality.

10. I Make Sure I’m Buying from a Trusted Seller

I pay attention to who is selling the ice maker. A trusted seller usually provides accurate product information, responsive customer service, and reliable shipping. I prefer sellers with strong ratings and clear contact details. This lowers my chances of getting the wrong part or dealing with poor support after the purchase.

11. I Think About Long-Term Performance

I don’t just want an ice maker that works today—I want one that keeps working. I look for signs that the unit is built for steady use and that other buyers have had good long-term results. If my old ice maker failed because of repeated jamming, weak production, or electrical issues, I pay extra attention to those areas when choosing the replacement.

12. My Final Buying Tip

My best advice is to match the part carefully, read the details closely, and choose

Final Thoughts

In my experience, choosing the right ice maker for a Whirlpool side-by-side refrigerator comes down to compatibility, reliability, and ease of installation. I’ve found that focusing on the correct model fit and quality replacement parts can save time and prevent future issues. My takeaway is that a well-matched ice maker keeps the refrigerator running smoothly and ensures a steady supply of ice when I need it most.