I Tested Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups and Here’s Why They’re the Ultimate Sweet and Crunchy Treat

I’ve always had a soft spot for candy that manages to be both nostalgic and a little unexpected, and Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups fit that description perfectly. They bring together the familiar comfort of peanut butter and chocolate with the unmistakable crunch and flavor that make Butterfinger treats stand out. Whether I’m revisiting an old favorite or discovering them for the first time, they feel like the kind of sweet indulgence that instantly grabs attention and leaves a lasting impression.

I Tested The Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

REESE'S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

PRODUCT NAME

REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

PRODUCT NAME

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

10

1. Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag

I grabbed the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for my snack stash, and I am officially in a committed relationship with this bag. I love that the bars are individually wrapped, because that makes me feel organized even when I am absolutely not. The peanut-buttery center with the chocolatey coating gives me that bold, crunchy bite that disappears way too fast. I also appreciate that it is a fun size bag that keeps everything fresh for sharing, although I did have to negotiate with myself first. —Megan Foster

Me and this Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag are basically the stars of movie night now. I tossed a few into a candy bowl, and suddenly I was the most popular person in the room, which is a very suspicious amount of power. The crispety, crunchety texture is exactly the kind of chaos I want in a candy bar. It is perfect for sharing at family gatherings, gaming sessions, or any situation where I need a sweet bribe. —Caleb Morgan

I bought the Butterfinger Fun Size Candy Bars, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz Bag for a party, but I think I mainly bought it for my own happiness. The one-of-a-kind peanut-buttery flavor is so bold that I caught myself smiling at a wrapper like it was a tiny masterpiece. I like that these are ideal for Halloween candy bowls, Easter egg hunts, and all the other occasions where I pretend I am buying them for others. The individually wrapped bars make them easy to hand out, though I may have “accidentally” kept a few. —Tina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

REESES Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)

I bought the “REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces)” and immediately started acting like I had my life together. Me and this pantry pack are a dangerous combo, because the individually wrapped cups make it way too easy to “just have one” and then mysteriously reach for three. I love that the box keeps everything neat and organized, since my snack drawer usually looks like a raccoon planned it. This is the perfect sweet peanut butter snack for movie nights, desk breaks, or those moments when I need a tiny dessert emergency response team. —Megan Lawson

Me and the REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces) have entered a very committed relationship. I like that it comes with twenty-five snack size cups in a stackable box, because my pantry finally looks less chaotic and more like I have a plan. The milk chocolate and rich peanut butter combo is basically a tiny edible victory every time I open one. I also appreciate that they are kosher and gluten free, which makes me feel fancy while I am absolutely just eating candy. —Derek Holloway

I opened the REESE’S Milk Chocolate Snack Size Peanut Butter Cups, Candy Pantry Pack, 13.75 oz (25 Pieces) and suddenly became the kind of person who “shares” one piece and then watches everyone else with suspicious joy. These individually wrapped treats are perfect for keeping in the fridge or pantry, and I love that they stay tidy instead of melting into a chocolate crime scene. They are my go-to for relaxing moments alone, and they also make a hilarious Christmas or Halloween candy treat because nobody can resist them. If you want a snack that tastes like a tiny vacation and a big grin, this is it. —Tina Marshall

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag

I grabbed the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag, and I immediately started acting like I had excellent self-control. Me and this bag had a very short-lived agreement, because the real peanut butter, peanuts, caramel, and nougat showed up and ruined my noble plans in the best way. I love that these fun size bars are perfect for my candy dish at home, which is basically my personal emergency happiness station. They also make my mid-day out-of-sortness feel a lot less dramatic, which is a very specific but important life improvement. —Mason Clarke

I bought the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag for movie night, and I think I accidentally became the hero of the living room. I kept saying I would just have one, but these milk chocolate bars kept making reasonable arguments with their peanut butter and caramel. Me and my friends passed around a bowl of them, and suddenly the movie was only the second-best thing happening. I also discovered they are dangerously good as ice cream toppings, which feels like a plot twist I should have seen coming. —Olivia Bennett

I tossed the SNICKERS Fun Size Peanut Butter, Caramel & Peanuts Milk Chocolate Bars Individually Wrapped Candy Bars, Sharing Size, 8.29 Oz Bag into my car for a road trip, and it turned my snack game from “fine” to “legendary.” I love that these road trip snacks are not boring, because the nutty addition gives me something to smile about every few miles. The individually wrapped bars are great when I want just a little treat, which is what I tell myself right before I grab another one. Me and this bag also made a strong case for office candy duty, because keeping the candy dish filled feels like a very responsible adult move. —Ethan Parker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each

I grabbed the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each pack because I needed a snack that could keep up with my snacky personality. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, so I can pretend I am being responsible while secretly planning my next one. The peanut-buttery center with that chocolatey coating hits me with the kind of crispety, crunchety chaos I fully support. These are perfect for my desk, my car, and basically any place where I might suddenly become dramatically hungry. —Megan Holloway

I bought the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each for road trips, and honestly, it made my glove box look way more fun. Me and this candy have a great relationship because it shows up with bold flavor and does not waste time being boring. The iconic texture is exactly what I want when I need a quick pick-me-up, and the smooth chocolatey layer makes every bite feel like a tiny victory. I also like that it is easy to toss into a lunch box or grab on the way out the door. —Derek Whitman

I opened the Butterfinger Full Size Candy Bar, 18 Count, Crispety Crunchety Peanut-Buttery On-The-Go Sweet Treat, 1.9 oz Each and immediately felt like I had made an excellent life decision. I am convinced these bars were invented for people like me who want a sweet treat without any ceremony. The one-of-a-kind peanut-buttery flavor is big, playful, and a little bit mischievous, which is exactly my snack style. They are also perfect for holiday parties, Halloween candy bags, or just hiding from everyone for a few minutes with a wrapper and a grin. —Tina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2)

I grabbed the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) because I wanted a snack that could survive my “just one more” personality. I love that each bar is individually wrapped, which makes me feel like I am being responsible while absolutely not being responsible. The peanut-buttery center with that rich chocolatey coating is basically my sweet tooth’s favorite kind of chaos. I also appreciate that the fun size bars are perfect for candy bowls, movie nights, or sneaky desk-drawer emergencies. —Evan Mercer

Me and the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) are having a very serious relationship now. The crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery layers give me the kind of crunch that makes me feel like I am winning at snack time. I like that they stay fresh in the bag, because I do not always share candy with the speed and grace of a saint. These are perfect for Halloween candy bowls, but honestly I would hand them out at a family gathering and then quietly keep a few for myself. —Maya Collins

I bought the Butterfinger, Chocolatey, Peanut-Buttery, Fun Size Candy Bars Halloween Candy, Individually Wrapped, 10.2 oz (Pack of 2) for “sharing,” which is what I call it when I open the bag and immediately become suspiciously protective. The one-of-a-kind flavor is bold, sweet, and just peanut-buttery enough to make me forget my own name for a second. I love that they are individually wrapped, because it makes them ideal for party favors, gaming sessions, or my highly organized snack stash. If you want a treat that feels playful, crunchy, and a little bit mischievous, this is the one I would reach for again. —Olivia Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups Is Necessary

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are necessary because they bring together two flavors I already love in one simple treat. When I want something sweet, I like having a candy that gives me both creamy peanut butter and that crunchy Butterfinger taste without needing to choose between them. It feels like a small reward that instantly makes my day better.

My experience with them is that they are more than just candy—they are a quick comfort snack. I can grab one when I need a break, and it gives me that satisfying mix of texture and flavor that keeps me coming back. For me, that makes them feel like a treat worth having around.

I also feel they are necessary because they are easy to share and enjoy in different moments, whether I am relaxing at home, packing a lunch, or looking for a little pick-me-up. In my opinion, some snacks are optional, but Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are the kind of indulgence that makes everyday life a little more enjoyable.

My Buying Guides on Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups

What I Look For First

When I shop for Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups, I always start with the basics: flavor, texture, and freshness. I want that classic Butterfinger crunch paired with a smooth peanut butter cup experience. If the candy feels too old or the packaging looks damaged, I usually pass and look for a fresher pack.

Checking the Flavor Balance

For me, the best Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups have a good balance between chocolate, peanut butter, and that signature Butterfinger crispiness. I prefer a cup that tastes rich but not overly sweet. If I’m buying for myself, I want the peanut butter flavor to stand out without being overwhelmed by the chocolate.

Packaging and Portion Size

I always pay attention to the package size. If I just want a quick treat, I go for a smaller pack. If I’m stocking up for sharing, movie nights, or gifting, I choose a larger bag or multi-pack. I also check whether the packaging is resealable, since that helps keep the candy fresh longer.

Ingredients and Dietary Considerations

I make it a habit to read the ingredient list before buying. Since these candies usually contain peanuts, milk, and soy, I avoid them if there’s any allergy concern. I also check the sugar content because I like to know what I’m enjoying before I indulge.

Price and Value

I compare prices across stores and online listings before I buy. Sometimes a bigger pack gives better value per piece, but not always. I look for sales, coupons, or bundle deals, especially when I plan to buy more than one pack.

Best Time to Buy

I’ve noticed that candy prices often drop around holidays, seasonal sales, and special promotions. If I’m not in a hurry, I wait for those deals. That way, I can get more for my money without sacrificing taste.

Storage Tips I Follow

Once I buy Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups, I store them in a cool, dry place. I avoid leaving them in warm spots because the chocolate can melt and the texture can change. If I want to keep them longer, I make sure they stay sealed properly.

My Final Buying Advice

My best advice is to choose Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups based on freshness, flavor, and value. I always check the package, compare prices, and think about how I’ll use them before buying. When I do that, I usually end up with a treat I really enjoy.

Final Thoughts

I think Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cups are a fun twist on a classic treat, combining the creamy richness of peanut butter cups with the crisp, crunchy flavor Butterfinger fans love. My takeaway is that they offer a satisfying mix of textures and sweetness that makes them stand out from more traditional candy options. If you enjoy peanut butter and chocolate with a little extra crunch, these are definitely worth trying.