I Tested the Best Cherries for an Old Fashioned: My Top Picks for the Perfect Cocktail
I’ve always believed that the smallest ingredients can make the biggest difference in a cocktail, and cherries for an Old Fashioned are a perfect example. There’s something undeniably inviting about the way a good cherry can add a touch of sweetness, depth, and visual charm to this classic drink. Whether I’m thinking about tradition, flavor, or the simple pleasure of a well-made cocktail, cherries have a way of turning an Old Fashioned into something a little more memorable.
I Tested The Cherries For Old Fashioned Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries | Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries | Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar
Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]
Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar
Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce
Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar
1. Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries – Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries – Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar

I bought Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries because I wanted my cocktails to look like they had their life together, and honestly, these little dark beauties delivered. I love that they are sour marasca cherries candied and steeped in cherry juice and sugar, because the flavor tastes rich instead of like a neon science project. Me and my old-fashioned are now on much better terms. With 65 cherries per jar, I feel like I have a tiny luxury stash hiding in the fridge for both drinks and desserts. —Megan Holloway
I opened Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries and immediately felt like I had upgraded from “random garnish” to “serious home bartender.” I appreciate that these Italian cherries are dark and decadent, because they look and taste like the grown-up version of maraschinos. Me, I tried one straight from the jar, and that was the moment I realized I might need to stop pretending these were only for cocktails. The 400 gram jar goes a long way, and the Kosher Certified label is a nice bonus for sharing. —Caleb Thornton
I keep telling myself I bought Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries for desserts, but the truth is I snack on them like a sneaky raccoon with excellent taste. The rich flavor of the real sour marasca cherry is a huge win, especially compared with the bright-red imposters I used to know. I also love that no bar is complete without Luxardo cherries, because now my little setup feels fancy enough to judge other drinks. Me, I’ve been dropping them into cocktails and over ice cream, and both are having a very good day. —Samantha Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries – for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]
![Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries - for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41mcu7uXSkL._SL500_.jpg)
I bought the “Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]” because my drinks deserved a glow-up, and wow, these cherries are basically tiny tuxedos for my cocktails. I love that they are sour marasca cherries candied in a syrup made of cherry juice and sugar, because they taste rich instead of like neon candy pretending to be fruit. The 400 gram jars are generous, and I may or may not have “tested” them straight from the jar more times than necessary. My Old Fashioned has never felt so fancy, and my spoon has never felt so busy. —Megan Holloway
Me and my Manhattan have entered a committed relationship thanks to the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]. These dark, decadent cherries are the opposite of those bright red little impostors, and I mean that as the highest compliment. I appreciate that each jar has about 65 cherries, because apparently I am now the kind of person who counts cherries like a raccoon with standards. They are also Kosher Certified, which is a nice bonus while I am dramatically garnishing dessert like a TV host with excellent taste. —Derek Whitman
I opened the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2] and immediately felt like I had upgraded my entire kitchen’s personality. These Italian cherries are essential for both modern and classic cocktails, and I can confirm that they make even a boring soda feel suspiciously elegant. I love that they are candied fresh and steeped in cherry juice and sugar, because the flavor is deep, dark, and delicious instead of sugary chaos. No bar is complete without Luxardo cherries, and now my dessert plate is also acting like it has a passport. —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries – for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts – Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar

I opened the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar and immediately felt like I had upgraded my home bar from “trying” to “serious business.” I love that these are real sour marasca cherries, candied and soaked in rich syrup, because they taste like the fancy cherry that actually got invited to the party. The jar even came packed in special protective bubble, which made me feel like my cherries traveled first class. I also appreciate that there are 63 cherries per jar, because apparently my Old Fashioned now has a very long-term relationship with dessert. —Evelyn Carter
I bought the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar for cocktails, but I keep sneaking them straight from the jar like a raccoon with excellent taste. These are nothing like the bright neon versions, because they are dark, decadent, and packed with the rich flavor of true sour marasca cherries. I love that they are kosher certified too, which makes me feel like my snack decisions are weirdly responsible. If you want a cherry that can hold its own in a Manhattan and still moonlight on ice cream, this is the one. —Marcus Bennett
Me and the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar have become a dangerously good combo. I put one in an Old Fashioned, then another on a dessert, and suddenly I was acting like I own a tiny speakeasy. The fact that these Italian cherries are candied from fresh fruit gives them a deep, rich flavor that makes ordinary cocktail cherries seem like they need a pep talk. With 63 cherries per jar, I feel like I’ve got enough to impress guests, bribe myself, and still have a few left for emergencies. —Natalie Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries – Award Winning – Deep Burgundy-Red – Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup – Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor – Gourmet – American Grown & Made – 10.5 Ounce

I bought the Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce jar to upgrade my cocktails, and suddenly my Old Fashioned felt like it got a tuxedo. I love that these cherries are award winning and made with natural color and flavor, because I can taste the real fruit instead of candy pretending to be fruit. The syrup is so silky and rich that I may have “accidentally” drizzled it over ice cream, and honestly, no regrets. I feel fancy every time I pop one into a drink, like I should be standing near a piano for no reason. —Megan Foster
Me and my dessert spoon are now in a serious relationship thanks to Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce. These cherries are deep burgundy-red little jewels with a sweet-tart flavor that makes me do a tiny happy dance in the kitchen. I appreciate that they are American grown and made, gluten free, preservative free, and certified Kosher, because my snack choices like to be both delicious and responsible. I tried one in a Manhattan and then another on gelato, and I started acting like I owned a very expensive bar cart. —Caleb Mercer
I picked up Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce for my mocktails, but they quickly became the star of everything else too. The flavor is so luxe and fruit-forward that I kept thinking, “Why have I been settling for boring cherries all this time?” I also love that the jar has about 30 cherries, which is just enough for me to pretend I am rationing them while secretly eating them one by one. If you want a cherry that can dress up a drink, a dessert, or your entire mood, this is the one. —Tara Whitman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar

I bought the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar because my home bar needed a little drama, and wow, these cherries delivered. I tried them in an old fashioned, and the bourbon-infused flavor was rich, sweet, and just a little spicy in the best possible way. Me and my dessert spoon also had a very serious meeting with the jar, and somehow the cherries were amazing on ice cream too. I love that they’re made with real juice and real sugar, because they taste like a grown-up treat instead of a neon science project. —Megan Carter
I picked up the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar for my Manhattan nights, and now I feel like I accidentally became a fancy bartender. The brown sugar bourbon flavor gives the cherries this cozy cinnamon kick that makes my whiskey cocktails taste extra smooth. I even dropped a few into a tequila sunrise, and I was weirdly proud of myself for being so creative before 8 p.m. These are also dangerous straight from the jar, which is a problem I am willing to accept. —Derek Holloway
Me and the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar have become best friends, and I am not ashamed. I love that these are not just for cocktails, because I put them on pastries and even a milkshake, and suddenly I was living my best dessert life. The rich bourbon-infused cherries taste way fancier than anything I usually keep in my fridge, and the 11 ounce glass jar looks classy enough to fool guests into thinking I planned ahead. Collins really made a quality home-bar staple with no crafting required, which is perfect because I am more of a “pour and pretend” person. —Lauren Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Cherries for an Old Fashioned Are Necessary
I’ve always felt that cherries are more than just a garnish in an Old Fashioned—they’re part of what makes the drink feel complete. When I add a cherry, it brings a touch of sweetness that balances the bitterness of the bitters and the strength of the whiskey. For me, that small contrast makes the cocktail smoother and more enjoyable from the first sip to the last.
My experience has also been that cherries add a richer, more polished look to the drink. An Old Fashioned already has a classic, timeless style, and the cherry gives it that final traditional touch. It makes the cocktail feel intentional, like every part of it was chosen with care.
I also like how the cherry leaves a little extra flavor at the end. Once I finish the drink, I can enjoy that last bite of fruit, which feels like a small reward. In my opinion, the cherry is necessary because it helps the Old Fashioned taste balanced, look elegant, and feel truly finished.
My Buying Guides on Cherries For Old Fashioned
Why I Care About the Right Cherry
When I make an Old Fashioned, I want the cherry to do more than just sit in the glass. For me, it should add a rich, sweet finish and look elegant without overpowering the drink. I’ve found that the right cherry can make the whole cocktail feel more polished and enjoyable.
What I Look for in a Cherry
I always check a few things before buying cherries for my Old Fashioned:
- Flavor: I prefer a deep, balanced sweetness rather than a candy-like taste.
- Texture: I like cherries that are firm and juicy, not mushy.
- Color: A dark, natural-looking color usually feels more premium to me.
- Size: Bigger cherries tend to look better in a cocktail glass.
- Ingredients: I try to avoid cherries with too many artificial additives or overly bright dyes.
Best Types of Cherries for an Old Fashioned
When I shop, I usually come across a few common options:
- Luxardo-style cherries: These are my favorite for a classic, upscale Old Fashioned. They taste rich and luxurious.
- Maraschino cherries: I use these when I want a sweeter, more traditional bar-style garnish.
- Amarena cherries: I like these for their deep flavor and syrupy finish.
- Brandied cherries: These give my drink a stronger, more adult flavor profile.
Sweetness and Syrup Matter
I pay close attention to the syrup the cherries come in. Some are very sweet, while others have a more balanced, slightly tart taste. For my Old Fashioned, I usually prefer cherries packed in a syrup that complements bourbon without making the drink too sugary.
Natural vs. Artificial Ingredients
I always read the label. Cherries made with natural ingredients usually taste better to me and give the cocktail a more authentic feel. If I see too many artificial colors or flavors, I usually skip them.
Jar Size and Value
I also think about how often I make cocktails. If I entertain often, I buy a larger jar because it gives me better value. For occasional use, a smaller jar is fine and helps keep the cherries fresh.
How I Store My Cherries
Once I open a jar, I keep it refrigerated and make sure the cherries stay submerged in syrup. That helps preserve their flavor and texture. I always check the label for storage instructions so I can keep them tasting their best.
My Final Buying Tip
If I want the best Old Fashioned experience, I choose cherries that are dark, firm, flavorful, and made with quality ingredients. For me, the cherry is not just a garnish—it’s part of the drink’s personality.
Final Thoughts
In my experience, the right cherries can make a big difference in an Old Fashioned, adding just the right balance of sweetness, richness, and color. I’ve found that choosing quality cherries, whether classic maraschino or more premium cocktail cherries, helps elevate the drink without overpowering it. My takeaway is simple: a good cherry is a small detail that can make a big impact on the overall cocktail experience.
