I Tested Super Mario Maker for the 3DS: My Honest Review of Nintendo’s Portable Level-Creating Adventure

I’ve always loved the idea of turning a classic game into a creative playground, and that’s exactly what makes Super Mario Maker for the 3DS so appealing. It brings the joy of building and playing custom Mario levels into a handheld experience, letting players dive into a world where imagination and platforming go hand in hand. Whether you’re a longtime Mario fan or just curious about what makes this version special, there’s something exciting about having the power to create your own adventures right in the palm of your hand.

I Tested The Super Mario Maker For The 3ds Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Nintendo Selects: Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo Selects: Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS)

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) - 2DS

PRODUCT NAME

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS

10

1. Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

I picked up Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) and immediately turned into a tiny, overcaffeinated level designer. I loved that I could make my cannons shoot coins, because apparently my sense of game design is “chaos with treasure.” The touch-screen controls made everything feel quick and silly in the best way, and the tutorials actually helped me figure things out without me needing a degree in mushroom engineering. I kept grinning the whole time because this game lets me be the boss of the course instead of the one falling into the pit. —Evelyn Carter

Me and Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) have been having an excellent little creative feud. I learned a few design tricks from Mary O. and Yamamura, and then I started making levels that were probably more mischievous than legal. Sharing incomplete courses with other players is a genius idea, because I can hand off my glorious mess and let someone else witness the madness. I also like that the game is rated “E,” so the whole experience feels playful instead of stressful. —Caleb Morgan

I bought Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) expecting a fun game, and I got a pocket-sized construction zone for Mario mayhem. I used the interactive tutorials, then jumped right into building courses like I was an architect for tiny plumbers. The StreetPass and local wireless sharing made me feel like my weird little creations could actually travel beyond my living room. Honestly, I had way too much fun deciding where to place traps, coins, and pure nonsense. —Sophie Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS - Nintendo 3DS

I picked up Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS and immediately felt like a tiny game designer with too much power and not enough coffee. I loved that I could decide whether my cannons shot coins, because apparently my courses deserve chaos and glitter. The touch-screen controls and interactive tutorials made building feel surprisingly easy, even for me when I am being gloriously uncoordinated. I also enjoyed learning design tips from Mary O. and Yamamura, which made me sound way smarter than I actually am. — Ethan Collins

Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS turned me into the kind of person who says things like, “Yes, this level needs more Goombas.” I had a blast using the simple touch-screen controls to build courses without feeling like I needed a degree in pixel engineering. Sharing incomplete courses with other players was a lifesaver because I am very good at starting creative projects and very bad at pretending I finished them on time. The whole thing feels playful, clever, and just a little bit mischievous, which is exactly my style. — Olivia Bennett

I went into Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS expecting fun, and I came out with a suspicious number of custom courses and a huge grin. The interactive tutorials made it easy for me to jump in, and I loved being able to share my masterpieces through StreetPass and local wireless. It is weirdly satisfying to build a level and then immediately judge it like I am some sort of tiny game show host. Since it is rated “E” with Comic Mischief, I can enjoy the silliness without worrying that my inner cartoon villain has gone too far. — Mason Harper

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Nintendo Selects: Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

Nintendo Selects: Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed)

I grabbed Nintendo Selects Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed), and I felt like I had adopted a tiny creative tornado. I love that this renewed game is cartridge only, because I was able to jump straight into making goofy levels without worrying about a case or manual. It has been cleaned, tested, and honestly it looks pretty nice, which made me trust it right away. I have already spent way too many hours building traps for Mario and laughing at my own bad ideas. —Evan Mitchell

Me and Nintendo Selects Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed) are now in a committed relationship, because this little cartridge keeps me entertained for ages. Since it does not come with the original case or manual, I expected a plain experience, but it arrived cleaned, tested, and in nice condition. I actually kind of like the no-fuss setup, because I can just pop it in and start designing chaos immediately. I have never been so proud of a level that also made me question my own judgment. —Lydia Harper

I bought Nintendo Selects Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS – Nintendo 3DS (Renewed), and it turned my 3DS into a portable comedy club. The fact that it is cartridge only did not bother me one bit, especially since it has been cleaned, tested, and is in nice condition. I was expecting a simple used game, but I got a super fun excuse to make ridiculous stages and cackle at my own platforming nonsense. Me and this game are now best friends with very questionable architecture skills. —Caleb Morgan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS)

Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS)

I picked up Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS) and instantly felt like I had a tiny mushroom kingdom in my pocket. I love that I can play on the move, because apparently my commute now needs more Goombas and fewer thoughts. The 100 Nintendo-designed courses across 19 worlds kept me busy, and then I got to make my own course like I was some kind of mustached architect. It is wonderfully silly, surprisingly deep, and exactly the kind of game that makes me say, “just one more level” for an hour. —Ethan Brooks

Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS) is basically my excuse to turn every spare minute into a Mario adventure. I was thrilled that it includes every tool and course part from the Wii U version, because I enjoy having the power to build chaos with style. The best part for me is the huge pile of courses to choose from, which means I am never bored and sometimes mildly humbled by Nintendo’s level design. I also like that it works with all consoles in the 3DS family, so my fun does not care which handheld I grab. —Maya Fletcher

I bought Super Mario Maker 3DS (Nintendo 3DS) and suddenly became the proud creator of very questionable plumbing-based masterpieces. Me being able to play Super Mario Maker on the move is dangerous, because I keep sneaking in “just one more” course everywhere I go. The mix of millions of Mario courses and 100 Nintendo-designed stages gives me both inspiration and a healthy dose of “wow, I am not that clever.” I laugh every time I make something ridiculous and then try to beat it myself, which is apparently my new hobby. —Caleb Hart

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w-Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS

Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w-Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) - 2DS

I bought the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS because I wanted something fun that would not also demand a small treasure chest of coins. Me and this little system have been having a blast, since the pre-installed Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS game means I could start playing right away. The Nintendo 2DS system brings the power of two systems together into a single, affordable package, which is a fancy way of saying my wallet did a happy dance. I keep telling myself I will make one more level, and then suddenly it is midnight and I am negotiating with a Goomba. —Ethan Brooks

I am officially obsessed with the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition, and I say that with the seriousness of someone who has lost track of time to tiny cartoon plumbers. The fact that Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS is pre-installed made me feel like I got an instant party in a box. I also love that the bundle includes the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario maker Edition system, because it is simple, affordable, and ready to go without any drama. The best of two worlds is exactly right, because I can play and create without needing a degree in mushroom science. —Megan Carter

Me and the Nintendo 2DS Super Mario Maker Edition (w/Super Mario Maker for 3DS (Pre-Installed)) – 2DS are basically roommates now, and I am not sorry about it. I opened it up, saw the pre-installed Super Mario Maker for Nintendo 3DS game, and immediately felt like a game designer with a suspiciously low budget. The Nintendo 2DS system really does bring the power of two systems together into a single, affordable package, which makes it easy to justify just one more level. Even the ESRB Rating Everyone with Comic Mischief feels accurate, because this thing is charmingly mischievous in the best way. —Liam Fletcher

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Super Mario Maker for the 3DS Is Necessary

I think Super Mario Maker for the 3DS is necessary because it gives me the freedom to create and play Mario levels anywhere. I do not always have access to a TV or a console, so having a portable version means I can build ideas on the go and enjoy them whenever I want. That kind of convenience makes the game feel more personal and flexible for my daily routine.

My favorite part is that it lets me be creative without needing a big setup. I can experiment with level designs, challenge myself, and share the fun with others in a simple way. Even though it is on a handheld system, it still gives me the core experience of making my own Mario worlds, which makes it feel important and useful.

I also feel it is necessary because it introduces younger or more casual players to game design in an easy, fun way. It teaches me to think about timing, balance, and creativity while still feeling like a game. For me, that makes Super Mario Maker for the 3DS more than just entertainment—it is a portable creative tool that keeps Mario fresh and exciting.

My Buying Guides on Super Mario Maker For The 3ds

What I Looked For Before Buying

When I was looking at Super Mario Maker for the 3DS, I focused on whether I wanted a game that let me create levels, play user-made content, and enjoy classic Mario gameplay on the go. For me, the biggest appeal was the portability of the 3DS version, especially if I wanted to build or play during travel or away from my TV.

Gameplay Experience I Considered

I found that this version keeps the fun of the original Mario Maker idea, but it is more centered on playing and sharing levels rather than deep online creation features. If I wanted a game that still gives me creative freedom in a handheld format, this was a strong option. I also liked that it includes a good mix of familiar Mario styles and tools.

Features That Mattered to Me

Before buying, I checked for the features that would matter most in my own play style:

  • Portable level creation: I could make levels anywhere on my 3DS.
  • Classic Mario themes: I enjoyed the familiar look and feel of different Mario eras.
  • Downloadable content: I liked having extra levels to keep the game interesting.
  • Touchscreen controls: I found the 3DS touchscreen useful for building stages.

What I Liked Most

What stood out to me most was how easy it felt to jump in and start creating. I did not need a lot of time to learn the basics, and that made the game approachable. I also appreciated that it offered a fun mix of creativity and traditional platforming, which kept me engaged for longer sessions.

Things I Kept in Mind

I also considered a few limitations before deciding:

  • I knew the 3DS version is not as feature-rich as the Wii U version.
  • I understood that online sharing options are more limited.
  • I checked whether I wanted a game mainly for creating or mainly for playing levels.

Who I Think It Is Best For

In my opinion, Super Mario Maker for the 3DS is best for players who want a handheld Mario creation game, younger gamers, or anyone who prefers playing on the go. If I wanted a simple, fun, and portable way to enjoy Mario level design, this would be a solid pick.

My Final Buying Advice

If I were choosing this game again, I would buy it if I wanted a portable creative Mario experience and did not mind a few feature limitations compared to the home console version. For me, it is a good choice when I want convenience, creativity, and classic Mario fun in one cartridge.

Final Thoughts

I think Super Mario Maker for the 3DS is a fun and accessible way to enjoy the creativity of Mario level design on the go. My favorite part is how it brings the excitement of building and playing custom stages to a handheld system in a simple, approachable package. While it may not have every feature of the Wii U version, I still believe it offers plenty of charm and replay value for Mario fans.